- John McCall MacBain 2021-2024
- Michael Meighen, 2014-2021
- Arnold H. Steinberg, 2009-2014
- Richard W. Pound, 1999-2009
- Gretta Chambers, 1991-1999
- Jean de Grandpr茅, 1984-1991
- Conrad F. Harrington, 1976-1983
- Stuart M. Finlayson, 1975 (April to December)
- Donald O. Hebb, 1970-1974
- Howard I. Ross, 1964-1969
- Ray E. Powell, 1957-1964
- Bertie C. Gardner, 1952-1957
- Chief Justice Orville Sievwright Tyndale, 1947-1952
- Morris Watson William, 1943-1946
- Edward Wentworth Beatty, 1920-1943
- Robert Laird Borden, 1918-1920
- William Christopher Macdonald, 1914-1917
- Donald Alexander Smith, (Baron Strathcona and Mount Royal), 1889-1914
- James Ferrier, 1884-1888
- Charles Dewey Day, 1852-1883